Thanking donors works, just not the way you think

Kris Van Kerkhoven • 3 July 2026

Share this article

Thanking donors works, just not the way you think


Picture this: a donor clicks "confirm" after an online gift. Two minutes later, an email lands in their inbox. Automatically generated, polite, smooth. And for most donors, entirely expected.


The question is whether that email still does anything for the relationship.


Over the past few years, a strong consensus has formed in fundraising around the thank-you process: thank donors fast, for every gift, as automated as possible. The logic sounds sound. But both research and practice tell a more nuanced story.


What the research says


McConkey Johnston International studied the effect of personalized thank-you letters on new donors. First-time donors who received a personal thank-you within 48 hours gave again four times more often. The key word here is "personal": not a generic confirmation, but a thank-you that read as if it had been written specifically for that person.


Penelope Burk's research, gathered in her book Donor-Centered Fundraising, confirms this. Burk asked donors what had prompted them to make a second gift. 45 percent pointed to an excellent thank-you letter after their first gift as the deciding factor. Not the campaign. Not the newsletter. The thank-you.


At the same time, the Abila Donor Loyalty Study shows that 71 percent of donors feel more engaged with an organization when they receive personalized content. Not more content. Not faster content. Personalized content.


Taken together, these three findings point in the same direction: the quality and relevance of a thank-you determine its effect, not the volume.


A thank-you process versus a thank-you strategy


There's a real difference between the two.


A thank-you process sends the same email for every gift, a few minutes after the transaction. It scales, and it ticks a box. But as a relational gesture, it doesn't amount to much.


A thank-you strategy deliberately decides which donor gets which form of recognition, and when. It builds on what's already sitting in your CRM: giving history, thematic interests, communication preferences, involvement in projects. And it's willing to say that not every gift deserves the same follow-up, but every valuable relationship deserves real attention at the right moment.


That takes decisions. Which triggers do you define? A first gift. A third gift within one year. The move to monthly giving. A donor who gives again after years of inactivity. For each of these moments, you decide which channel and which content fit.


Personalization that goes beyond name and amount


Plenty of nonprofits claim to personalize, but what they mean is that the first name and gift amount get pulled into the email automatically. That's a start, but donors can tell the difference between an email that's "for them" and one that's actually written "to them."


Real personalization builds on several layers.


The first is relationship context: how long has this person been a donor, what's their giving pattern, are they also a volunteer or an ambassador?


The second is thematic interest: which projects or themes has this person historically supported? What content do they open and click on?


The third is the content link itself: the thank-you explicitly references those themes and shares news that's relevant to that specific person.


Say a donor has supported your bee project every year for the past two years. It would be a shame to open the thank-you email with a long story about hedgehogs and mention, almost in passing, that "something's also happening with bees." It's far stronger to open with a concrete update on that bee project, name one result, and let the donor feel it: "We know what matters to you."


Old school: handwritten cards for a select few


There's still something to a handwritten card. Everyone knows it takes time, and that's exactly why it feels sincere. An organization can't do this for every donor, but it can deploy it strategically.


Each week, pick 20 to 25 donors from your CRM based on a meaningful criterion, such as a first gift, an anniversary year, or a reactivation, and write them a short, personal card. You'll send fewer than with a mass mailing, but each card is a clear signal that someone is more than a record in a database.


AI as an assistant, not a shortcut


Personal thank-yous remain the ideal. The more a donor feels a thank-you was written specifically for them, the stronger the effect. But no one can thank thousands of donors personally, one by one. That's not a shortcoming, it's simply a matter of time.


So the question isn't whether to personalize or automate. The question is finding the right mix. For a limited group, the donors for whom a genuinely personal moment makes the difference, a personal approach remains the best choice, as with the handwritten card mentioned above. For the rest, the volume you simply can't write yourself, the question isn't whether to automate, but how well you do it.


That's where AI comes in. Not as a replacement for the personal relationship with your donors, but as a way to bring the part of your thank-yous that has to happen in bulk as close to personal as possible. The alternative to AI, after all, isn't a personal letter for everyone. The alternative is a generic, one-size-fits-all letter that isn't really aimed at anyone.


But how AI gets used makes all the difference.


AI as a shortcut produces text that looks personalized but isn't. Research shows that a significant share of online donors say opaque AI use would make them less inclined to give. That's not a reason to avoid AI, but it is a signal that quality control has to happen upfront, in the setup and the safeguards, not as an afterthought.


AI as a strategic assistant works differently. You start by building a content pool: excerpts from annual reports, project updates, impact stories, internal reporting that's cleared for sharing. That pool is put together deliberately.


You then feed the system with CRM data per donor: interests, giving behavior, communication preferences. Based on that, the system writes a personalized email, tailored to that specific person.


Quality control doesn't sit in reviewing every email after the fact. It sits in what you configure upfront. Which topics, phrasings, or situations should never appear in a thank-you email? At what thresholds, an unusually large gift, a sensitive situation, a particular donor profile, should the system route a case to a human instead of sending it automatically? Once those criteria are set, the system can run on its own, without anyone checking every single email.


That's how you combine scale with depth. Hundreds of thank-you emails that genuinely reflect who the donor is, fully automated, without losing relevance.


From automation to attention


Sending more thank-yous isn't the fix. Better thank-yous are. Every layer of automation, every layer of personalization, every handwritten card serves the same purpose: making a donor feel seen, not counted.


What matters is the quality and relevance of every touchpoint. The willingness to say that not every gift gets a personal follow-up, but every valuable relationship gets the right attention at the right moment. And the willingness to stop treating your CRM as a transaction database and start treating it as the foundation of a relational strategy.


Donors notice the difference. The question is whether we, as fundraising professionals, notice it just as clearly.


Fundflow is the Salesforce-based CRM solution for fundraising, built for Belgian and European nonprofits. With features for donor history tracking, segmentation, and communication automation, Fundflow helps organizations turn their thank-you process into a genuine stewardship strategy.


Fundflow is a product of Impactella.


Sources



  1. McConkey Johnston International. The effect of personalized thank-you letters on donor retention. Cited via SOFII. https://sofii.org/article/how-thanking-can-transform-your-relationship
  2. Burk, P. (2003). Donor-Centered Fundraising. Cygnus Applied Research. https://www.cygresearch.com/donor-centered-fundraising
  3. Abila (2016). Donor Loyalty Study: A Deep Dive into Donor Behaviors and Attitudes. https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/abila-donor-loyalty-study-finds-content-and-personalization-key-to-donor-loyalty-across-generations-and-income-levels-300250649.html
  4. Kindsight (2025). Donor Stewardship Guide for Nonprofits (incl. 2024 retention figures). https://kindsight.io/resources/blog/individual-donor-stewardship/


Want to know where your organisation stands on data quality?

Fundflow helps nonprofits structure their Salesforce environment so every gift, every contact, and every interaction lands in the right place. 

Recent Posts

Een man met bril en baard luistert aandachtig naar een collega aan een tafel
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 10 November 2026
AI maakt bouwen eenvoudig. Een CRM met gegevens van schenkers vraagt controle. Zo pakken we het aan en dit willen we van fondsenwervers horen.
Un homme à lunettes et à barbe écoute attentivement une collègue à une table
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 10 November 2026
L'IA simplifie la création d'applications. Un CRM avec des données de donateurs exige du contrôle. Notre approche et notre question aux fundraisers.
A man with glasses and a beard listens attentively to a colleague at a table
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 10 November 2026
AI makes building easy. A CRM with donor data needs control. Here is how we approach it and what we want to hear from fundraisers.
Des personnes échangent des papiers autour d'un ordinateur portable dans une salle de réunion
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 3 November 2026
Le SPF Finances renouvelle Belcotax on web pour les attestations fiscales des dons. Ce qui change, ce que cela implique pour vous et que régler avant février.
Mensen wisselen papieren uit rond een laptop aan een tafel in een vergaderruimte
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 3 November 2026
FOD Financiën vernieuwt Belcotax-on-web voor de fiscale attesten van giften. Wat verandert er, wat betekent dat voor jou en wat regel je best vóór februari?
People exchanging papers around a laptop at a table in a meeting room
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 27 October 2026
FPS Finance is renewing Belcotax-on-web for donation tax certificates. What changes, what it means for you and what to sort out before February.
Une coureuse est enlacée par deux amis après l'arrivée d'une petite course solidaire dans un parc.
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 22 October 2026
Les actions peer-to-peer amènent beaucoup de nouveaux donateurs, mais la plupart ne donnent qu'une fois. Voici comment les suivre dans les 90 premiers jours.
A runner is hugged by two friends after crossing the finish line of a small charity run in a park.
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 22 October 2026
Peer-to-peer campaigns bring in many new donors, but most of them give only once. Here is how to follow up with them within the first 90 days.
Een loopster wordt na de finish van een kleine benefietloop in een park omhelsd door twee vrienden.
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 22 October 2026
Peer-to-peer acties brengen veel nieuwe schenkers binnen, maar de meesten geven maar één keer. Zo volg je ze op binnen de eerste 90 dagen.
Two people in conversation at a meeting table, a fundraiser meeting a corporate partner
by Kris Van Kerkhoven • 14 October 2026
Fundflow's new Corporate Fundraising module tracks corporate partners from first conversation to commitment, in the same CRM as your donors.
Show More